Isadora 3 Pricing: Please Read and Respond

hairi

after some thought these are my considerations:

Since I use Isadora , must be 15 -years now (licence 00077), I use it professionally.

These years Isadora has contributed in various ways (from RAD, to pre-viz to deploy) to more than 50% of my income.

Many of my Isadora projects still work standalone after years, mostly on windows machines after being developed on mac. (Tells it all)

The actual money I ever spent for the software is way less than the smallest job I ever did.

So even if the price triples, for a pro it's almost "shareware" compared with what it actually is capable of (including the superb community).

The other software packets I use a lot are all open-source and fully capable of professional use too. (SuperCollider, Processing/Eclipse, Arduino, GLSL).

But nothing can do what Isadora does when it come to my actual improvised workflow.

Off course not all users do earn their living (yet) by using Isadora (or are happy to have a pro-hobby), and as much that I stress the pro angle of pricing I am in favour of easy access for beginners.

But then it's not all money isn't it ? There is another element that could be strengthened in this context:

Transmission of (pro) experience in exchange for contemporary ideas, half-ideas, thoughts. I am 62 years of age and in the biz for more than 20. I was a professional sound engineer before. I know what a gig is. I have my ideas (old-fart?), know-how, experience et cetera. I currently have no pupils. I would like to have one and am prepared to pay for his licence for a limited period in exchange for discussing ideas and sharing patches. My gain would be to keep living happily out-of-touch with contemporary (mostly juvenile) technology-adrenaline while being informed somehow. Another gain is to learn from a pupil.

That's what I think.

Kind regards to everybody

Hairi

Fred

@mark is there an ETA on V3?

Woland

@fred said:

@mark is there an ETA on V3?

Mark asked me to tell you all that the officially-planned release is in Fall 2018 with October 15th being our target date, though there is the possibility that this may get pushed back slightly to ensure that we can deliver the best product possible to the community.

Best wishes,

Woland

vjw

As a regular user of Isadora, I prefer the buy to own, but whether I teach Isadora or just evangelize, a major problem is the inability to save. I would advocate for a free download that allows saving, but only uses a bare-bones Isadora, so that students can learn to put together the actors and create very basic scenes. Like the actors that are used in the basic tutorials. (Picture player, movie player, sound movie player, projector, dots, wave generator, envelope generator, and the like). Then, if they want to subscribe or buy or rent to buy, the options are available at the regular pricing. Speaking of which, as a modern dancer directing a small company, I obviously prefer the lower pricing while still wanting to be fair to Mark and the team. So I upgraded to a 2.0 license for my USB key, but am waiting to upgrade my 1.0 standard license until 3.0 comes along. I really appreciate the support in the forum for my problems, and the support from the team when there is an Isadora and not just a user (me) problem.

Woland

@vjw said:

As a regular user of Isadora, I prefer the buy to own, but whether I teach Isadora or just evangelize, a major problem is the inability to save. I would advocate for a free download that allows saving, but only uses a bare-bones Isadora, so that students can learn to put together the actors and create very basic scenes. Like the actors that are used in the basic tutorials. (Picture player, movie player, sound movie player, projector, dots, wave generator, envelope generator, and the like).

While I'm not authorized to give an official decision on this, I feel that making, monitoring, testing, distributing, maintaining, and providing support for another unique format of the software would be extremely time consuming for our team, (especially @mark). That being said, we are doing everything we can in order to make Isadora accessible to artists and everyone else that wants to try it out. To this end, the new subscription model offers a full week of the software for only $10.

We did this for:

Professors/teachers who may be spending a week teaching Isadora to students as part of a course or workshop at an academic institution which does not have enough licenses for each student to use a licensed (save-enabled) version of Isadora instead of running it in demo mode (no saving).
People without Isadora licenses, such as an undergraduate students, who want to use Isadora for a short-term project.
Try-before-you-buy situations in which saving is required.
Workshop attendees who want to be able to save (and work while saving for a few days afterwards).
Companies, designers, and theaters who only need to use the software for one week (or two non-consecutive weeks) in a performance/installation situation.
Artists/designers need a license for a short period of time in order to be able to make tweaks to the programming of a project that they build with Isadora because they are remounting/adapting/updating it.
Short events like hack-a-thons, contests, and programming "jam sessions".

Personally, I think this is an excellent solution, and that the price is extremely reasonable for a week of the save-enabled software.

Armando

Hello all,

I'd like to add a thought here. I teach and evangelize a lot since 2000 (0.7 b). Students would love to save I would go for a watermarked video output and for sound (sound coud "buzz" every 2 min for example) but with the ability to save.

Woland

@armando said:

I'd like to add a thought here. I teach and evangelize a lot since 2000 (0.7 b). Students would love to save I would go for a watermarked video output and for sound (sound coud "buzz" every 2 min for example) but with the ability to save.

While we thank you very much for this suggestion and for your insight, at this time we are not planning to offer a limited-feature/watermarked version of Isadora as an option upon the launch of Isadora 3. That being said, this idea has been something we have discussed previously and may consider implementing at some point in the future.

I know exactly how you feel. When I teach workshops, even to friends for free, I've always wished that my workshop attendees without their own Isadora license could save their work. The ability to save makes an enormous difference when it comes to being able to remember what you've done, (even if the instructor gives you example files as part of the workshop). While we do not currently offer a free, save-enabled version of Isadora our hope is that the short-term $10 Isadora license will address most of the situations in which a limited-feature+watermarked version of Isadora would be desirable. Additionally, the revenue provided by offering inexpensive short-term licenses will assist us in flourishing as a company so that we can continue to support our wonderful community of Isadora Users. Another added benefit of maintaining our current demo method is that we are able to offer a free version of Isadora that has no limitations on any of Isadora's features (except for saving). This is extremely useful for designers and artists who need to program a show or an installation, leave it running, and then move onto using their Isadora license on their next project while the first show/installation continues to function using only the fully-featured, save-disabled version of Isadora.

Best wishes,

Woland

Armando

@woland

I really hope you are right. In my university I bought 13 licences and we give keys to students so, there is no problem. But can I ask why the watermarked solution is not viable one for the team? Some years ago @Mark told me that he didn't want the low res solution because some VJ still were using the res as low as 320x240. I understand that, but is it still the case? I really think that low res watermarked/or limited res solution could be a good one. And it shouldn't be too difficult to create.... Saving disabling has always been a pain for me because to progress I need to save. Max/msp or Ableton live where bad for me because I need to study on periods more than a month. I buyer them, but younger students might be frighted to invest. Especially dancers... who are faaaaar from technology.

Armando

@mark I am very glad of the addition!!!! Nice to have the choice. I'll tell my students.

dbini

Any idea of the ETA of Izzy3? and does the new pricing come into effect at the same time? I've got a bunch of students hooked on Isadora and the university wants to buy a license, but i recommended they wait until the new educational discount is in the system.