Kinect v2 Actor on Mac?
I know you are working on 20 things at the same time, but just going to ask the question here :)
If you are done with the Kinect v2 would you be able to share it along so we can report issues / etc ? We are currently exploring it for a remote piece that we are doing.
@mark and all,
I am always really intrigued by the comparison of Kinectv1 and Kinectv2 on the Mac platform. As far as I can tell from reports and my own experience with using the v2 on Mac with NiMate there are resolution, speed and range improvements and differences. It appears to me that the extended features of the v2 have been locked out of Mac software development. Features like hand (thumb) and face tracking don’t appear to be possible on Mac. Is this true or are there other features of the v2 that will be significant for a OpenNi Tracker in Isadora?
axelacs last edited by
Any update on Kinect v2 OpenNi Tracker and Skeleton Actor please let me know. best
axelacs last edited by
I am intrigued too. And I would like to know too if the extended features are/will be available on Mac. best
mark last edited by
Features like hand (thumb) and face tracking don’t appear to be possible on Mac. Is this true or are there other features of the v2 that will be significant for a OpenNi Tracker in Isadora?
Yes, that is true that the features you mention are not avaiable on macOS. That is because those features are not part of the open source/hacked driver for Kinect v2 on that has been cobbled together for macOS. The features you mention only available on Windows if you use Microsoft's official Kinect v2 SDK.
We have discussed on the team whether or not we should make a Windows only tracker that allows access to those features. But I am always concerned about having features on one platform that are not on the other.
mark last edited by
To everyone following this thread, a status report:
As I have alluded to elsewhere, I have an internal build of OpenNI Tracker that captures and body tracks using the Kinect v2 capturing on macOS. However, I do not have the same working on Windows.
The open source system on which OpenNI Tracker is based only accepts an image of 640x480 or 320x240. The macOS driver that hackers/programmers have created (libfreenect2) converts the Kinect v2's 512x424 pixel image to 640x480, allowing it to track.However, since the Windows version grabs the image using the Windows SDK, it is not the right size.
It is my intention to port the resolution conversion in libfreenect2 for macOS to Windows to solve this problem. But with all the guru sessions, coding new plugins (Screen Capture, NDI Watcher with audio) I simply haven't gotten this done yet. It is high on my priority list though, and now that we've added some features important to remote performance -- a topic that seems urgent at the moment -- I will turn my attention to getting Kinect v2 working for both platforms.
I guess I could release the Mac version for thsoe who want to use it, but I hate creating situations where there are special versions and users get confused. That always costs us money because we have to pay people to offer techincal support -- either here on the forum or via our ticket system.
Let me see how quickly I can get this stuff done. I want you all to have it, but there are only so many hours in a day.
Hi @mark, thanks for your time,
where can I find the internal build you mention here?
Mac16 2020, Catalina 10.15.7
m working with this one but keeps on crashing when i connect the kinect v2.
m sending the crash reports every time Isadora opens again (i just sent 3 crash reports)
Any idea why is this happening ?
What model number of Kinect V2 do you have?
I have a 1520, and can test it on Mac tomorrow. I have a Catalina machine so that should be a good test.
Mine is also model 1520
The Kinect is working when i use it via windows bootcamp, Touch designer.
I am experiencing the same crash on Mac with the Kinect v2 running on an Intel based Mac running Catalina.
I have submitted crash reports with details, so we will be able to look deeper into this.
The Kinect running via Bootcamp shows that the hardware is good.. so that is helpful.
The OpenNI actor is working as expected on Windows for me as well. So this appears to be a Mac only issue.