Forum Update - Everyone Please Read [UPDATED Apr 13, 2018]

DusX

I am having trouble using the forum menu (unread topic, latest topic etc.. ) on my Android now. Previously this was no problem.

DusX

The menu opens when tapped but only closes again when tapping any menu option. Doesn't load the associated page.

Juriaan

I have the same issue on my android phone.

mark

@dusx said:

am having trouble using the forum menu (unread topic, latest topic etc.. ) on my Android now. Previously this was no problem.

Ryan, would you say this describes the issue?

https://community.nodebb.org/t...

If so, I'll have our programmer apply the fix they suggest there.

Best Wishes,
Mark

DusX

@mark

Yes I think it might be. I also checked for a chrome update but I seem to have the latest already.

Woland

I'm on my laptop, (Macbook Pro in my signature), and sometimes replying to topics makes the edit window automatically over-fill the screen. Everything above the basic a paragraph, formatting, image, file, upload, etc. is off the screen and so I can't grab the little black circle with the double-ended arrow in order to drag it down and see the post while I'm replying. Furthermore, it won't allow me to type when it does this. Any ideas?

Best wishes,

Woland

Woland

Update:

I came back to edit my comment and add that I had been on Chrome, found I couldn't edit my comment, so I tried to make a reply, but got the bug again.
I tried and had the same issue on Safari, Mozilla, and Opera on my Macbook, but arguably worse because I couldn't even see the formatting buttons on most of those.
Issue did not happen with Chrome on my iPhone 6+.

The good news is I figured out what makes it happen and how to get around it.

The Issue: As that as you scroll down through a thread the default "height" that the top of reply window will start at seems to change, thus when I reply to my comment all the way down here, the top of the reply window is WAYYY off the top of the screen. Because that little black circle is the only way to resize the window, (i.e. it's the only way to move the top of the window up and down), and that little black circle is wayyy off the screen, you're stuck with your entire browser window basically just being white nothing (maybe with the formatting buttons at the top).

What fixes it: Replying to the original post instead of a comment (gives you a normal reply window instead of a white wall).

I think this is further evidence that the cause of the problem is that the reply window's default position seems to be tied to how far down or up in the thread you scroll.

Steps to recreate:

If you go to the original post and press "reply" you get a normal forum reply window where you can write, have access to the white double-arrow inside the black circle at the top left (which allows you to move the "top" of the reply window up and down).
- Press "Discard"

Press "reply" as if you were replying to the first commenter.
- For me, then "top" of the reply window appeared higher on the screen by default than if I were replying to the original post.
- Press "Discard"
Press "reply" as if you were replying to the second commenter.
- For me, then "top" of the reply window appeared higher on the screen by default than if I were replying to the first commenter.
- Press "Discard"
If I repeat this process, moving down to the next commenter, then the next, etc., I very soon end up with a "white wall".

I can't type, I can't reach the top in order to resize it, and the "Discard" and "Submit" buttons are even off the screen so I can't junk the "white wall" reply.
I can, however, press the red circle at the bottom right to hide the white wall (as it is just a reply window).

If I then reply to the original post again, I get a normal reply window (though I have no way to close the white wall reply and the red circle stays there until I refresh the page).

@Michel any ideas?

Best wishes,

Woland

Woland

Also not sure if I've just forgotten, (after two months away from the forum working another job), how to edit my replies after I've already made them, or if I'm actually unable to edit my comments anymore.

L

Michel

@woland

I can confirm this problem. I don't think we can solve this our self. Maybe Tobias could solve this. If this happens you have to click the red button at the bottom right, then scroll all up to the first post and then click the red button again and the edit window appears normal.

You should be able to edit your posts. If you click on the 3 dots on the right side underneath your post, there should be the word edit.

bonemap

@mark

I am having some difficulty using the forum interface on iOS (iPhone 8) latest release. There does not appear to be any functional options to navigate the forum. I can’t access chat messages or notifications, I am also unable to go between posts. It appears the only thing I can do is go back to the Isadora entry page and re-select the forum to load it again. It is pretty much dysfunctional for me.

Best Wishes

Bonemap

Michel

@bonemap @mark

Yes I have the same issue on my iPhone 6s with Safari, I cannot navigate at all through the forum. I can call the menu but I cannot select anything in it.

Best Michel

Woland

@Michel

Sad to say those three dots were the first thing I tried. It only gives me the option to bookmark for some reason

Best wishes,

Woland

Woland

@Michel

Also, that was me trying to edit my own comment. When I click on the dots for other people's I get the normal "Favourite" and "Flag for moderation" options.

Best wishes,

Woland

mark

@Woland,

First, fantastic find regarding the workaround for the editor problem. Thank you.

Second, to everyone, I'm sorry for the trouble. As I said originally, we had no choice but to move to the latest build b/c of all the crashes.

Regarding the reply problem, which I can see easily on Safari, Firefox and Chrome

I have submitted a bug report on NodeBB's github as you can see here:

https://github.com/NodeBB/Node...

I've also posted about it in their forum in the bug reports section:

https://community.nodebb.org/t...

But since I don't have a smartphone, if you feel the toolbar issue people have mentioned is different than the one I submitted, can I ask you set up a github account (if you don't already have one) and submit a detailed description of the bug there and also to post it on NodeBB's forum.

Thanks for handling this Lucas. ;-)

Best Wishes,
Mark

Woland

@mark

Note that on long original posts like the one linked below, my workaround is useless because one needs to scroll down to far in order to reply to the original post.

Also, sometimes I'm getting the reply window in the right place, but all the formatting buttons are mysteriously absent.

Discarding the current reply window and trying again usually brings the formatting buttons back.

https://community.troikatronix...

Edit:

Workaround for Replying to Threads with Long Original Posts.

1) Zoom browser view out (until the "reply" button and the top of the first post are both visible).

2) Reply to the original post.

mark

@woland said:

Note that on long original posts like the one linked below, my workaround is useless because one needs to scroll down to far in order to reply to the original post.

Well, this workaround works for me, regardless of the number of posts:

1) Hit reply button... editor fills the frame, etc.
2) Hit the little red button with the "speech balloon" and three dots to hide the reply
3) Scroll to the first post
4) Hit the red button again
5) Now you can successfully enter text, apply formatting, etc.

Best Wishes,
Mark

Woland

~~Worth noting that the the fix above doesn't work for editing one's own replies.~~

Best wishes,

Woland

Edit: I was wrong. It does work for editting one's own replies.

Woland

Workaround for Replying to Threads with Long Original Posts.

1) Zoom browser view out (until the "reply" button and the top of the first post are both visible).

2) Reply to the original post.

Edit: Mark's workaround is better.

mark

Dear Community,

So, the NodeBB folks finally came up with a patch that at least solves the problem where you can't reply unless you're at the top of the forum list. This works for me on multiple browsers.

But what about people on with phones? Is the toolbar appearing in the right place now and working for you?

@DusX @mc_monte @Woland please report back.

Best Wishes,
Mark

bonemap

@mark

Hi,

I can report that the navigation elements still do not function at all on iOS Safari, iPhone 8. But the reply function is working well.

Best wishes

Bonemap